America's Oldest
Wine Cellars
Excavated by hand in the late 19th Century, the dimly lit cellars house over 200 oak barrels.
TOUR INFO
Weddings
Brotherhood Winery offers several venues on our property for your special day.
Grand Salon

“The purity of our wines was our pride and first consideration.”

– Charles Jaques, 1839-1886

Halloween Ball

Saturday, October 24

Step into our historic cellars for a night where vampires mingle, wine flows, and the music never dies.

Expect bold costumes, a lavish dinner buffet, an open wine bar, and a packed dance floor. Undercover judges will be roaming throughout the night, rewarding the most creative looks with bottles of Brotherhood wine.

Public Tours & Tastings

$25 per person

Available Tuesday-Sunday.

Tours go out as groups gather. No reservations needed.

Each guest will choose 5 wines to taste from a catalog of 15 wines in this guided tasting option.

Guests receive a one-ounce serving for each wine.

The catalog of 15 wines is constantly being updated, but will always consist of a combination of varietal and traditional selections.

Tour guide Michael Itskowitz explaining champagne fermentation at Brotherhood Winery aging vaults

Santa's Slay

Interactive Comedy Murder Mystery Dinner

Just hear those “slay” bells ringing when someone delivers a stocking full of murder at the annual Elfin Christmas party. Become one of Santa’s little helpers as you try to solve this holiday mystery. Join us for a holly jolly good time, and a bit of murder under the mistletoe.

Saturday, December 5, 2026
7:00 PM
$120 per person

Journey back to where wine-making is an art.

America’s Oldest Winery is only about an hours drive from New York City.

Since 1839

Nearly two centuries of American winemaking.